So, on Reddit (not a good place, I know), the most upvoted comment to a post saying “You get a call from a woman and it makes you angry. Who is she?” was “Ellen ‘Degenerate’”. (Their words, not mine). Since it was hugely upvoted, why is she so bad? All I know is that she is a talk show host and a lesbian.


Yeah, they do, but this was in the past. 2008. Article: The Mercury News
I’d go as far to say that back then people would still have the old fashioned idea that all celebrities are “masterful drinkers” who are allowed one or two glasses of champagne in the middle of the day with ellen degeneres.
As such, they have narrow-minded views towards sobriety.
Ergo, Carey’s options are
#1 is true, short, and something people would have found out anyway.